This place will at all times maintain a particular place in our hearts as a result of Beech Grove Pizza Firm is the a centesimal pizza place in Indiana that we have visited! This place was beneficial by April and after we noticed photographs on-line of the quirky nostalgic horror theme we simply needed to see for ourselves.
The Principal Avenue strip of Beech Grove may be very cute and quaint on the southeast aspect of Indianapolis contained in the beltway. On the drive by means of we even discovered one other pizza place that wasn’t on our map but. We have been welcomed by a rainbow flag for delight month and chalk sidewalk drawings.
Inside we sat by the window to get higher mild for photographs, and there are two areas related by a passthrough between the eating space and bar space. Each wall had a painted mural that includes some type of nostalgic character from 80’s and 90’s traditional horror films or simply cult classics generally like RoboCop for some cause. Gremlins II was enjoying on the TV and I distinctly keep in mind listening to the band Rubbish’s 1998 hit “Push It” enjoying as background music. I am undoubtedly the goal demographic!
On-line listings for this place are a little bit in all places. I’ve seen it known as Beech Grove Pizza Co, Scarlet Grove Pizza Pub, Scarlet Grove Public Home – I feel perhaps it began as a restaurant for Scarlet Lane Brewing that began making extra of a reputation for itself with pizza to end in its personal branding?
After we sat down there have been 3 flies circling the desk, and I assumed oh no that is going to be a complete dive what have we gotten into. Our server was extraordinarily pleasant and good, and as soon as the meals began popping out I forgot all in regards to the flies and so they principally saved to the window and chilled anyway.
We began with Stuffed Styx that are your selection of stuffed breadsticks with pepperoni, sausage, or bacon with scorching honey. It was a little bit odd that there wasn’t cheese contained in the breadsticks, however they have been nonetheless implausible with simply sufficient crisp on the skin and fluffy on the within.
All of the pizzas and sandwiches have cute punny names referring to horror or nostalgic movies. Chris acquired the Springwood Slasher (loaded pepperoni) and I acquired the Eerie Indiana (rooster bacon ranch).
The crust was puffy with a superb quantity of chew however not an excessive amount of, and the toppings have been implausible. The ranch wasn’t too ranchy it was good. The crust form of jogged my memory of Huge Woods, however Chris says it is approach higher. It is undoubtedly fats on the perimeters however nonetheless sturdy sufficient within the center to carry the toppings. I like the swimming pools of garlic butter sauce and ranch as the bottom on mine.
That is one other place that looks like a vacation spot we might take out of city visitors, undoubtedly well worth the drive to see this quirky place that really has the meals to again up the gimmick!